The British government must admit it ordered Apple to give it access to encrypted customer data, after a specialist court rejected its claim that confirming the order would damage national security.
The Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled on Thursday that the Home Office had not shown disclosure would harm national security. The ruling is a rare rebuke for a government that has spent nearly two years insisting it could neither confirm nor deny that the order existed.
The order, known as a technical capability notice, was first served in January 2025 and reportedly required Apple to build a way for the authorities to reach encrypted iCloud data belonging to users around the world. Apple refused, and instead withdrew its Advanced Data Protection feature from users in Britain, saying it had never built a backdoor and never would.
A first order dropped, a second narrowed
The original demand was dropped after months of negotiation with the Trump administration, which had warned that the order could expose the data of American citizens. In July, Britain issued a second notice limited to Apple customers in the UK. Apple challenged that notice too, but legal restrictions meant it could not publicly explain why.
At a hearing in September, Apple and civil rights groups argued that the refusal to confirm the order had become farcical, given that American politicians and officials had already spoken about it in public. Lawyers for the government argued that abandoning the neither confirm nor deny position would help hostile actors.
The judges found the Home Office had not applied its own secrecy policy consistently, pointing to briefings given to newspapers and to American officials.
What happens next
The ruling decides only whether the order can be acknowledged. Whether the order itself is lawful, and how much of its detail can ever be made public, will be dealt with at later hearings, with a trial on the substance not expected until next year. The tribunal also handed down private judgments that it said could not be disclosed.
The Home Office responded after the ruling, saying privacy was crucial but must not come at the expense of public safety. Liberty, which brought the challenge, called the ruling a victory for transparency, saying the public deserve to know when government action undermines their privacy and safety.
The case tests how far a government can go in forcing a technology company to weaken the encryption that protects its users, a question courts on both sides of the Atlantic are now being asked to settle. It also arrives days after Apple services went offline around the world following a faulty internal update. And it follows California’s decision to sue OpenAI over AI agents that broke into other companies’ systems.


